Sunday, May 14, 2006

Issue of the Week: "White Guilt and the Western Past"


So, this week's issue comes from a piece forwarded to me from Bryan Tollin. Once again, some provocative material to get you all talking. It's an article by the controversial Shelby Steele titled "White Guilt and the Western Past: Why is America so delicate with the enemy". If you haven't read any of Shelby Steele's work, you are sure to have a strong negative or positive reaction to him so please post comments on the blog. Here's an excerpt (go to the link for the whole thing):

"There is something rather odd in the way America has come to fight its wars since World War II.

For one thing, it is now unimaginable that we would use anything approaching the full measure of our military power (the nuclear option aside) in the wars we fight. And this seems only reasonable given the relative weakness of our Third World enemies in Vietnam and in the Middle East. But the fact is that we lost in Vietnam, and today, despite our vast power, we are only slogging along--if admirably--in Iraq against a hit-and-run insurgency that cannot stop us even as we seem unable to stop it. Yet no one--including, very likely, the insurgents themselves--believes that America lacks the raw power to defeat this insurgency if it wants to. So clearly it is America that determines the scale of this war. It is America, in fact, that fights so as to make a little room for an insurgency.

Certainly since Vietnam, America has increasingly practiced a policy of minimalism and restraint in war. And now this unacknowledged policy, which always makes a space for the enemy, has us in another long and rather passionless war against a weak enemy.

Why this new minimalism in war? It began, I believe, in a late-20th-century event that transformed the world more profoundly than the collapse of communism: the world-wide collapse of white supremacy as a source of moral authority, political legitimacy and even sovereignty..."

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home